Becoming a (better) Service Designer — Designerly Thoughts From Yosef
(Note: Sadly, Medium does not support tooltips. To get the full experience of this article, you have to read it where I originally published)
1. Who is this for?
While respecting the difference between knowledge and mastery of a subject1, my goal in this article is to give readers an understanding of the nature of services and provide them with some tools so they can begin thinking critically about how services can be improved. Since service design is fundamentally an application of Human-Centered Design (HCD), readers will benefit from having a basic understanding of HCD’s process and principles before proceeding.2 Finally, if you have not done so already, I strongly recommend you start by watching my introductory video:
2. What makes Services Different: Service Characteristics
serv·ice / ˈsərvis/
* n. 1. the action of helping or doing work for someone
-Oxford English Dictionary
Every field of design develops specialized knowledge and skills necessary to craft a particular facet of the human experience.3 Most of what sets service design apart from other design fields are that services are:
- Intangible — They can’t be held or touched4
- Dynamic — They occur over time
- Perishable — They only exist while being provided and used
- Inseparable — They involve the interactions and contributions of multiple actors (aka. “stakeholders”)
- Variable — They can never be perfectly replicated5
Take, for example, the common service of giving someone a haircut: unlike automobiles, magazine ads, or smartphone apps, haircuts can’t be produced ahead of time and stored until a customer decides to purchase it. For this service to exist, the hair stylist and their client must both be present and work together to co-create their shared service experience. Furthermore, no matter how many times the same client visits the same stylist, the experience of the service can never be exactly the same.6
Another important consideration of services — which I might nest under the fourth bullet (“Inseparable”) above — is the fact that they have both “front stage” and “back stage” actors. For example, in most restaurants customers will interact with a host, their server, and possibly a busser — but never with the owner, kitchen staff, or the distributor from which the restaurant sources their ingredients.
An awareness and appreciation of the above service characteristics is the first pillar of designing services.
3. How to Design a Service: Service Components
Even though services themselves are intangible goods, they emerge from the orchestration of many tangible and intangible components (known as “touchpoints” when they’re experienced).
One way to consider the relationship between touchpoints, services, and ecosystems
With the end goal of creating great customer experiences, most of a service designer’s job involves choreographing everything that needs to exist and occur in order to support this experience.7 Using the same haircut example as before, we might consider the following:
- Place: What does the salon look, sound, and smell like? Where is it located? Is there a waiting area? Does it provide a place for kids to play while their parents are getting their hair done?
- Props: What kind of chair does the customer sit in? What tools does the stylist use to cut hair? Is there a television for customers to watch during their haircut?
- Price: How much does the stylist charge for their services? Do they offer loyalty discounts? Do they expect a tip?
- People: What is the personality of the stylist? What are their skills? How do they interact with their customers? What interactions do customers have with other customers?
- Process: How can customers make an appointment? Does the stylist spend time reviewing styles with their customer? Do they wash the customer’s hair before cutting?
- Partnerships: From where does the stylist order their supplies? What credit cards can the stylist accept for payment? Does the waiting area have WiFi available for customers?
- Positioning: Does the stylist only use environmentally-friendly products? Has the salon positioned themselves as a place for children’s haircuts? Do they provide free haircuts to veterans or homeless people?
- Policies: Do they work by appointments only, or do they allow walk-ins? Does the stylist offer free touch-ups in the weeks following a haircut? Do they guarantee satisfaction or your money back?
Note: While the above “8 P’s” categorization is a handy device, the categories themselves are often fluid and overlapping. For example, chairs arranged in a waiting room may fall under both “place” and “props”, and the hair stylist is tangible, but their skills are not.
Choosing service components, determining the order in which they’re used, and deciding what should be visible8 can be thought of as the “levers and dials” that designers can adjust to choreograph the desired service experience. For example, consider how drastically different a haircut experience would be by just changing one thing: What if instead of having a traditional brick and mortar salon, a stylist provided house calls in a mobile salon bus? Or, instead of charging customers per appointment, what if a stylist offered annual subscriptions to their salon?
Additionally, because services comprise such a wide range of components, the number of ways to answer the question “How can we improve this service?” are almost limitless! Due to the breadth of scope, implementing new service offerings often requires coordination between many parts of an organization and collaboration with experts in other fields (e.g., interior designers, UX designer, change managers).
4. The Service Mindset
There are four ways in which services can interact with products or other services, and each of these relationships may lead to innovative new service offerings. Let’s give our hair stylist a break, and move on to new examples:
1. Services can be wrapped around products
- A newly purchased car comes with two years of free tune-ups
- A car is leased to drivers instead of being purchased
2. Services can replace products9
- A car-sharing program obviates the need for automobile ownership
- A taxi service replaces the need to drive
3. Services can replace other services
- A grocery delivery services obviates the need for a taxi or car-sharing program
- A meal kit service replaces the need to buy groceries
4. Services can exist alongside other services as part of a larger service ecosystem or platform
- A meal kit service is part of a larger health offering along with a gym membership and a personal trainer
- A car-sharing program partners with restaurants, hotels, and other attractions to provide road trip vacation packages
To be clear, while most services today are designed around existing offerings, totally new services are also possible.
I have often said that “Service design is about creating the best experiential path to a desired outcome.” One of the most important parts of service design — or any design field — is being able to glean the deeper needs (i.e., the desired outcomes) that are driving human decisions. 10 Once the needs are understood, designers can begin creating products and services (i.e., experiential paths) to meet them.
Graphic from my article “Customer service is only one aspect of a service”
5. Service Design Tools
As stated at the beginning of this article, HCD is the foundation of service design — so it should come of no surprise that the skills and tools associated with HCD are heavily utilized by service designers when undertaking research, synthesis, facilitation, ideation, and storytelling. 11 However, in order to manage the characteristics and components of a service, most of service design’s most popular tools fall into the following categories:
- Visuals that give form and tangibility to service experiences — These visuals often showcase the interactions between multiple stakeholders (e.g., service blueprints12, stakeholder maps, business model canvases), or highlight the variety of different “journeys” that a stakeholder may take and the service components they’ll interact with (e.g., ecosystem maps, flowcharts, customer journeys). During research and synthesis, designers use these tools to discover where “pain points”, “moments that matter”, and potential “listening posts”13 exist in a service. During ideation and implementation, designers use these tools to build, refine, and communicate their ideas.
- Methods for prototyping and testing service experiences at various fidelities — These prototypes allow designers to imagine and play out how a service could work (e.g., business origami, bodystorming, speed dating), or allows them to test how successful aspects of a new service are with acting or real users (e.g., role playing, concept walkthrough, wizard of Oz). Prototyping tools often uncover new insights about a service, and enable designers to quickly refine experiences through on-the-fly improvements.
Ultimately, the best tool or method to use is the one that best serves the needs of your project. If the tools available to you are falling short, I recommend modifying an existing tool or creating a brand new one — and if it works well, please share it with the greater design community!!
Congrats! You’ve made it to the end! Hopefully, you’ve begun to see the world through service-tinted glasses and feel inspired and empowered to start tinkering with services. Sometimes lives can be difficult and unpleasant, but hopefully -together- we can make experiences worth having!
7. Next Steps
From the designers I’ve met, I know there’s no one “right way” to get into service design. That being said, here are my suggestions:
- Read, read, read — There are so many good SD books and magazines out now full of theory, tools, history, and, most importantly, case studies.
- Watch presentations from the Service Design Network (SDN) Global Conference — Many of the keynotes and presentations from past years are available online for free on Youtube.
- Take a class — Many certificate programs are offered online.
- Get a degree — Obviously a much larger investment of resources, but it’s now relatively easy to find SD programs at universities around the globe.
- Start using SD mindsets and tools — If possible, incorporate them into your real work — if that’s not possible, try applying them to your own life or personal projects.
- Participate in a Global Service Jam (GSJ)- The Jam is an annual design event that takes place simultaneously in over a hundred cities around the world. Find one and sign up!
- Get familiar with common software — You don’t have to be an expert, but it’s helpful to become familiar with the tools commonly used to create visuals, presentations, prototypes, and wireframes (e.g., Adobe CS, Office, iWork, Figma). Also — don’t forget to check out popular online collaboration tools (e.g., Mural, Miro, Slack, Basecamp).
- Start creating or applying for SD roles — Find a way to transition your current job into something more SD, try to be a collaborator on an existing SD project, or simply start applying for SD jobs directly! (another job link here)
- Join your local (or not so local) SDN Chapter — Attend events. Ask lots of questions. Don’t be shy. Meet and talk to people. Maybe I’ll see you there!
If you have any questions or suggestions, please feel free to reach out. 🙃
Originally published at https://www.yosefshuman.com on January 8, 2021.